공지사항

HOME

공지사항

교육정보

FAQ

공지사항

작성자

운영자	[ 작성일 : 2016-04-14 00:00:00 ]

제목

2016 MK 영어토론 대회 결과

2016 상반기 MK 영어토론 대회 결과

시상: 장A영(우면초 6), 최S연(영동중 1), 신J현(영동중 1), 허J원(은성중 2), 권C연(영동중 2)

논제: Professor Stephen Hawking, has expressed concern about what Artificial Intelligence such as AIpha Go might become one day. He said “The development of full artificial intelligence could spell the end of the human race. (by taking over the humans)” Do you agree or disagree with his opinion? Why? Debate.

평가: 100점(온라인 알림장 영어토론 발표와 반박 50점 + 오프라인 수업 영어토론 발표와 반박 50점)

Debate Scoring

Arguments

10 - All of the arguments were supported with an abundance of accurate evidence and examples and well elaborated.

8-9 - Most of the arguments were supported with accurate evidence and examples and were well elaborated.

5, 6, or 7 - Arguments were supported with some evidence and examples. Some information was inaccurate and/or not enough quality information.

1, 2, 3, or 4 - Arguments lacked evidence and support. Student relied too much on notes and /or too much inaccurate information.

0 – Student did not give any arguments.

Rebuttals

10 - All of the rebuttals adequately addressed each of the opponents’ arguments with sufficient evidence.

8-9 - Most of the rebuttals adequately addressed most of opponents’ arguments with sufficient evidence.

5, 6, or 7 - Rebuttals occasionally addressed some of opponents’ arguments with sufficient evidence.

1, 2, 3, or 4 - Rebuttals rarely addressed opponents’ arguments and/or did not present sufficient evidence.

0 – Student did not give any rebuttals.

Teamwork

5 - Student presented several different arguments and regularly defended their teammates arguments.

4 - Student presented several different arguments and occasionally defended their teammates arguments.

3 - Student presented some arguments but rarely defended their teammates arguments.

1 or 2 - Student presented few arguments and hardly ever defended their teammates arguments.

0 – Student did not participate.

Oral Presentation

5 - Student appeared extremely comfortable; spoke clearly and confidently. Good eye contact.

3 or 4 - Student appeared comfortable; spoke clearly. Eye contact could have been better.

1 or 2 - Student appeared uncomfortable; student did not speak clearly. Poor eye contact.

0 – Student did not participate.

Knowledge

10 - Student was clearly knowledgeable and well prepared.

8-9 - Student displayed an adequate understanding of the material.

5, 6, or 7 - Student appeared unsure at times and appeared to lack full knowledge of the material.

1, 2, 3, or 4 - Student was unprepared and lacked significant knowledge of the material.

0 – Student did not participate.

Respect

5- Student was respectful and followed the rules of the debate.

4- Student talked or whispered while others were debating.

2 or 3- Student did not follow the rules of the debate. Talked or whispered repeatedly while others were debating. Student made inappropriate comments.